How to approach it
Identify which law the question applies. The examples here use traditional common-law reasoning for services. A sale of goods may use different rules.
Read the exact response. An unconditional acceptance may be followed by a request. A response making agreement conditional on revised terms usually works as a counteroffer. Look for words like only if and unless.
Worked example
A painter offers to paint a room for $600 on Friday. The owner replies, “I accept only if you do it on Saturday.” The owner has proposed a Saturday bargain and made that change a condition of agreement. Under the assumed rule, this is a counteroffer.
Practice questions
The owner says, “I accept your Friday offer. Would Saturday be possible instead?” What is the best reading?
Show answer and explanation
The owner accepted and requested a change. The request does not make acceptance conditional.
The owner replies, “Would you consider $550?” Has the owner accepted?
Show answer and explanation
No. The reply asks about a different price and does not express assent. An inquiry alone is also distinguishable from a definite counteroffer.
The painter says, “I might take the job for around $600. I’ll send a quote next week.” Does this sound like a present offer?
Show answer and explanation
Likely no. The tentative language and promise of a later quote indicate that the painter is still negotiating.
Official reference
NCBE jurisdiction and admission information
What to study next
- Bar prep: Negligence issue spotting
Analyze duty, breach, factual causation, scope of liability and harm. Tie each element to a specific fact.