Browse exams / US Bar Exam

Bar prep: Negligence issue spotting

Analyze duty, breach, factual causation, scope of liability and harm. Tie each element to a specific fact.

How to approach it

Keep breach and causation separate. A defendant might have acted carelessly even if the injury would have happened anyway. For an ordinary single-cause problem, ask what would likely have happened without the alleged breach.

After factual cause, ask whether the injury fits the risk that made the conduct careless. If the facts leave the answer open, explain both readings and identify what evidence would resolve the dispute.

Worked example

A shop employee leaves a spill in a busy aisle for 30 minutes despite seeing it. A customer slips there and breaks a wrist. The facts support notice and a possible failure to clean or warn. The fall fits the risk created by the spill. If video instead shows the customer fell before reaching it, factual causation needs a different explanation.

Practice questions

  1. A guardrail is missing. A pedestrian falls because another person trips and pushes them, and evidence shows a rail would have stopped the fall. What fact supports factual cause?

    Show answer and explanation

    The evidence that the rail would have stopped the fall supports a but-for link. Analyze separately whether this kind of fall falls within the risk the rail should address.

  2. A spill appears one second before a customer slips. What would matter when evaluating breach?

    Show answer and explanation

    Whether the operator had actual notice, reasonably should have known, or could realistically have acted in that time. The short interval weakens the case for failing to discover it.

  3. A defendant drove carelessly but stopped without a collision, and the facts identify no injury or loss. What element needs attention?

    Show answer and explanation

    Harm. The facts show potential danger and no resulting injury or loss for the ordinary negligence claim.

Official reference

NCBE jurisdiction and admission information

What to study next